The North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation said in a statement Brandon Joyner, 24, surrendered around 12:30 p.m. and is being held without the opportunity for bond.
Joyner joins Chenail Jordan Jr., 25, as the second person in custody in the murder of Shuntavius Vaughan.
He and Jordan face charges of first-degree murder; attempted murder; assault with a deadly with intent to kill; shooting into an occupied dwelling and possession of a firearm by a felon.
The murder occurred at 305 Fields Drive at Conway Village Apartments and was the first in the Northampton County town since 2009.
The Northampton County Sheriff's Office reported late Friday night Vaughan, 24, of Conway, was shot and killed around 12:30 a.m. Friday
With Joyner and Jordan in custody, law enforcement continues to look for Akeem Robinson and Rumeal Daye, both 24. All the alleged suspects are from Conway. Robinson and Daye face the same counts as the two in custody.
They are considered armed and dangerous.
Anyone with information is encouraged to call 252-574-1041 or 911.