Fog

Roanoke Rapids, NC

63°F

Fog

Humidity: 100%

Wind: N at 0 mph

Tuesday, 26 April 2011 11:57

Justice: Perfect as it could be in two cases


Rate this item
(2 votes)

Two stories in Thursday’s edition have made us of think of crime and punishment.

They are the Tony Maurice Gorham story and the Jacob Davis story. Both of these stories show maybe the justice system is more just than we think they are.

Gorham received double life sentences for the Mother’s Day weekend murders last year and Davis received a suspended sentence that will force him to walk a tightrope or be faced with a long prison sentence for a series of break-ins and larcenies that ended with him allegedly setting fire to a church hymnal on a stove at Stanley White Presbyterian Church.

For those yelling to fry Gorham, let’s be honest, there will probably never be another execution in North Carolina for a long time, as the death penalty has become tied up in a Michigan State University study on the state’s Racial Justice Act.

We don’t think, however, the families of Maxine McCrary and Nancy Burgess were thinking about that study when they opted to allow prosecutors and defense attorneys to forge a plea arrangement that means Gorham will never walk out of prison alive.

As we yell and scream for death we are forgetting what happens in most death sentence cases, cases that even before the Michigan State University study were tied up in appeals and future cases that could be tied up indefinitely, including the Shelby Salmon and the Applebee’s murder case.

We are forgetting long appeals, we are forgetting the possibility of re-sentencing hearings, we are forgetting the emotional toll reliving the horror the facts of some of these cases will have on family members, who, when cases have to be retried, would have to hear them over and possibly over some more.

Halifax County District Attorney Melissa Pelfrey knew this Thursday. So did Gorham’s defense team. The case was a lock for investigators and the family of the two women didn’t want to hear gruesome details that so many of us love to hear. Pelfrey’s only comment, out of respect for the families, was that both women were stabbed multiple times but death was instant.

The families only wanted justice and we believe they got it with a sentence that assures them Gorham will never harm innocent people again.

The Davis sentence is another masterpiece of negotiation, although it might not seem like it on the surface.

It is a sentence that makes someone with a troubled past so accountable for what they did that if they look the wrong way they are in prison for some 158 months, some 13 years. For someone in their twenties, that’s a long time.

We don’t assume we know anything about Davis’ character. What we do know is for some people the probationary sentence he received would set them up for automatic failure with its list of do’s and don’ts that will force him to walk the upright path of a saint.

We know the justice system isn’t perfect, but on Thursday, we believe, the justice system was as perfect as it could be — Editor.

 

 

Lance Martin

Lance Martin

E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

comments  

 
+2 #4 Paula Barlowe 2011-09-20 05:23
They shouldn't get 5yrs to appeal. One yr should be ample enough time to appeal, with the cost of housing 1 one inmate per yr is twice as much as the average person makes a yr working, including their medical attention that they recieve, is far more than the average person, especially someone living on Social security, or disability. Why do they deserve the treatment they get?
Quote
 
 
0 #3 Sammy 2011-05-13 18:40
Concerning the death penalty... Give everyone 5 years in the appeal process to prove their innocence. After that, bring the guilty party back to Halifax. On Saturday afternoon have a public hanging. Invite the public. Encourage everyone to bring a picnic lunch. It would serve as a lesson to the younger generation on what happens if you break the law. Leave the person hanging til the buzzards start picking his/her carcus... Will bring back the true meaning of when a Judge tells someone, "May God have mercy on your soul!"
Quote
 
 
+1 #2 Michelle 2011-04-26 12:37
Well said Lance! It is natural for people to want the death penalty when a murder such as this is committed, but look at the facts. When someone is on death row in this country it costs the tax payers several million dollars to house them, provide not one, but 2 defense attorneys and appeal after appeal. Majority of the people on death row die before ever being executed. It costs an average $90,000/year to house a death row inmate. It costs an average of $45,000/ year to house an inmate. Life is simply the better choice for all involved. The victims families are not put through years and years of anguish and the offender is somewhere he will never hurt someone again.
Quote
 
 
-1 #1 Anthony Finney 2011-04-26 12:13
Well stated, Lance. It was due in large part to now retired Judge H. Paul McCoy, and his 2 year supervised probation sentence that was handed down to me when I was only 17 that elped me to straighten out my life quite drastically. The list that I had to adhere to while on probation was so strict, that my P.O. could violate me for nearly ANYTHING. Fortunately, Mrs. Burch saw that I was doing my best to change who I was and let me off relatively easy one time, and it was the only freebie I ever got from her. Probation for a criminal is worse than jail. It allows them the freedom of being in the public, and the rules of having a 24/7 police officer attached to there neck! You screw up on probation, and you could do your entire suspended sentence with no time granted for probation!
Quote
 

Add comment

All comments posted on rrspin.com must be written in complete sentences with no text message abbreviations. No all caps comments will be allowed, that includes words written in capital letters for emphasis.

There is to be no profanity and there is to be no character assassination even if the person being written about is a suspect in a crime.
Comments that presume knowledge of a person’s home life, financial situation or other personal details will be not be posted as will comments which presume legal knowledge.

All comments must be on the topic of the story and offer the reader’s insight on a particular issue. rrspin.com will cease posting comments if the editor determines readers are infighting with one another and not staying on the topic of a story.

rrspin.com prefers readers use their real names because anonymous posters are accountable for their comments just as readers who post their names are.


Security code
Refresh